PakCat catalogue record

Financial and Economic Analysis of Canal Lining in Pakistan 'Source Title' Proceedings Workshop on Canal Lining and Seepage 18-21 October, 1993 Lahore - Pakistan

By Muhammad Shafique

Bibliographic details

Summary

Rise in demand of water for food production needs exploration of new sources of water. National Commission on Agriculture (NCA) has projected that agriculture productivity must increase at 5% per annum, to meet the national requirements, compared with historical average growth of 3.8% per annum. To meet these objectives Water Sector Investment Planning Study has estimated additional requirement of water to the extent of 33.3 MAF at farmgate by the year 1999/2000. Lining of distributaries and minors has been identified as a propsective mode of increasing water delivery to farms. Economic potential from this source has been estimated to be 4 maf. The choice among alternative/competing development projects is made on the basis of least cost and optimum returns on investment. For comparison, costs per acre foot of water of various potential development alternatives of water resources have been computed. The economic cost per acre foot of water conserved from canal lining has been estimated to be Rs. 988 at farmgate whereas the economic cost of tubewell water is in the range of Rs 210 per acre foot. The financial implication to provide subsidey to farmers by the government for the development of electric tubewells in the private sector has been estimate4d to be Rs 100 per acre foot. Similarly government's share in the watercourse improvement, as computed from data in Feasibility Report of Command Water Management, ranges betweeen Rs 106 to 167 per acre foot. In case of canal lining, all cost, estimated to be Rs 1198 per acre foot of water at 1990 price level, has to borne by the government. Preliminary Economic Analysis of canal lining, based on marginal value of water, shows that canal lining is not feasible on economic efficiency criteria in fresh groundwater areas. The canal lining in saline groundwater areas is feasible, based on the level of costs and water saving. However experience reveals that the cost estimates, prepared during feasibility level, escalate during construction. It is therefore very essential to collect time series dat on costs and benefits on ongoing canal lining projects to confirm the economic analysis. The data may also be collected to meet the requriements to Indus Basin Model (IBM) to isolate the benefits of canal lining from other development activities which increase the agricultural productivity over time.