Implications of Warabandi System on Irrigation Management at Watercourse Command, Thesis for the Degree of M.Sc. (Honours) in Agricultural Engineering, 1994
Bibliographic details
Summary
In this study, the diagnosis of warabandi system and its implications on irrigation practices and water availability have bne studied. The system was designed about a century ago, and has not changed to accomodate the entirely different environments of today, and therefore facs a number of design and operational constraints to meet the system requirements. Possible solutions to the diagnosed problems and constraints have ben suggested in this present report. Several disparities were investigated in the distribution of water, filling and draining allowance, water trading practices, turn time and water charging system from technical as well as farmer's point of view. A questionnaire was prepared for interview the farmers to evaluate the trading practices, existing turn time, and water charging system during Rabi season, 1993. In the existing warabandi schedule, water is allocated to the farmers on the basis of their landholding by following a fixed rotation of turns (warabandi) without considering the conveyance losses. Due to heavy losses particularly in the unlined section of watercourses, watr supply decreases toward the tail end of a watrcourse. The inequity in water distribution was found up to 6 percent in lined section and 33 percent in the unlined sections of both the studied watrcourses. The actual filling and draining time for each share holder were observed and compared with those allocated by the Irrigation Department. Therefore, to overcome the inequity problem, a watr allocation model based on volume of water per unit area basis is proposed, that takes care of the conveyance losses and observed filling and draining allowances. The observed filling allowance varied from 1.12. to 2.66 and 3.24 to 10.27 minutes per 200 ft lenght in the lined and unlined sectinos of both the watercourses. The observed draining allowance varied from 2 to 3.37 and 4.5 minutes per 200 ft lenght of lined and unlined sectinos, respectively. Teh observed filling and draining allowances were found to be quite different than the existing values of filling and draining allowance i.e 5 and 3 minutes per 200 ft length of watrcourse, respectively. Some assumptions were made in the model formulation, which have negligible effect on the performance of model. Teh model does not consider any losses due to management inefficiency. The different proportional loss factors were calculated in the lined and unlined section of watrcourse, which were used in the model. The application of the model showed 100% equity in watr istribution among the shareholders of a watercourse command. The poposed watr allocation after considering the conveyance losses varied from 22.36 to 31.63 and 24.49 to 34.44 minutes per acre from head to tail for the WC 120620-R and 130118-L, respectively, as compared to the existing water allocation i.e 25.53 and 27.58 minutes per acre throughout the lenght of watrcourse. The existing and proposed water allocations were found to be equal at farm locations which constitutes 47% of total length from the outlet for WC. 120620-R and 64% for WC. 130118-L. Eighty three percent shareholders of watercourse No.120620-R accompished irrigations with trading practices among themselves within a season and between seasons. Water was traded for 8to 30 percent of the turns. Fifty eight percent shareholders of watercourse No.130118-L accomplished irrigations with trading practices and water was traded for 11 to 50 percent of the turns. This shows that more no of shareholders accomplished traded irrigation water on watercourse command having 7 days rotation cycle as compared to watercourse command of 10.5 days rotation. The average % area irrigated in each turn varied from 16 to 27% and 17 to 35% on WC 120620-R & 130118-L, respectively. This large variation was due to uncertainty condition of water availability. However the overall % area irrigated in eachf turn was found to be 22 & 24 % in the two watercourses, that shows that 1/4 to 1/5th portion of the area was irrigated in each turn, which is very less. Therefore, to overcome the problems of water trading practices and inadequacy of turn time, the turn cycle has been suggested to be increased. However, 100% farmers of WC 120620-R and 50% farmers of WC 130118-L favoured the 7-days rotation cycle, because of the following reasons. Shahkot distributary where both the watercourses are located usually remains in a state of uncertainty of water supply. The discharge fluctuates widely and is closed instantly without any prior intimation. Vegetable crops are grown, that require irrigation aftger every week. The tubewell water of this command area can not be used as an alternate due to brackish ground water. Ninety three percent of the shareholders were not satisfied with the existing method of water charging (Cropped area basis), as it has many drawbacks. Under the fixed warabandi system, the assessment can be related to number of turns, for which a cultivator receives his share of water. Considering the draining time, it was pointed out that the tail end farmer should be that farmer, whose net time should be greater than draining time. As observed in the WC 130118-l, the area of tail end farmer was 4.54 acres. The net time in the proposed warabandi schedule of that farmer was estimated to be 156 minutes based on average flow rate including the conveyance losses. The calculated draining time becomes 196 minutes. In this way, he is taking extra benefit of 40 minutes, which should go in the augmentation of net pool time to maintain equity. An alternate solution is that the draiing time should be allocated to the farmer whose allocated time according to his land holding should be greater than that estimated on average flow basis. According to the farmers, the ground water at the hed of distributary was nonsaline. Therefore, the farmers located at the head of distributary could use the tubewell water. If the outlet capacity at the tail of distributary could be increased as compared to the head of distributary. The farmers at the tail of distributary could pay the charges of excess water at the rate of tubewell water. The presented results are however on limited data from only two watercourses. The study focusses issues of great importance to the farmer. However, the investigations over a wider scale are recommended for acheving replicable results.