Historical Review of Water Resource Planning in Pakistan 'Source Title' Proceedings of the National Workshop on Water Resources Achievements and Issues in 20th Century and Challenges for the Next Millennium, Islamabad - Pakistan, 28-30 June 1999
Bibliographic details
Summary
In early years of irrigation development in the Indo-Pak subcontinent, water resource planning was relatively simple and based on the principle of sparsely spreading the river flows onto the farmland through man-made canal network. Planning became progressively more complex as other management aspects were also looked into as explained in the paper. In 1947, the division of sub- continent into two sovereign states forced the planners to re-plan the use of split water resources. These efforts, however, remained short-termed till the signing of Indus Water Treaty between India and Pakistan in 1960. The treaty gave a golden opportunity to water resource planners to comprehensively think and chalk out national development policies and investment plans. Indus Basin Projects implemented in the 60s and early 70s were the most important outcome of this planning exercise. Agricultural drainage was mainly ignored due to massive investment required in irrigation development and consequently the planners had to pay the price of unidirectional planning in the form of waterlogging and salinity, a major threat to the environment and sustainability of the Indus basin. To cope with this alarming situation, planners had once again resorted to unidirectional planning, this time not having much choice, and allocated a major portion of water sector investment for land drainage. Investment was partly focused for the improvement and rehabilitation of the irrigation system. During this period, the issue of water allocation among provinces became intensified and was resolved in 1991 by inking the Inter- provincial Water Accord. In the recent past, a balanced planning and implementation approach has been adopted and small-scale physical investments in private tubewells, watercourse improvement and soil reclamation have been accorded priority. Flood sector planning has been mainly curative with a little focus on preventive measures. Although research has been an integral part of all development plans, its contributions to planning and development efforts remain insignificant. Monitoring and Evaluation has recently gained importance but it is still project oriented and not based on a region or basin. A number of sectoral investment studies have been conducted and useful recommendations converted into actions. Such studies, however, should be replicated periodically so that water resource planning has always some solid base to rely upon and work with. Community participation in planning and subsequent elements of the project development cycle was absent until recently when the government took a radical shift from its traditional policy of agency managed irrigation systems to farmers managed systems. Similarly water resource development outside the Indus basin was largely neglected. The planners have now focussed on the potential and use of water resources outside the Indus basin. Better planning is not possible without better-trained people and this aspect must be addressed in its true perspective. The politics of water must change into the politics of development and national interest must prevail in planning and implementation activities. Institutional improvement should become a regular activity if organizational strengths are to be attained. Water resource policy encompassing all these and many other issues should be drafted, approved and implemented before entering into the next millennium. Although planning process has improved tremendously over the last 50 years, but its impact has not been visible due to a number of implementation bottlenecks listed in the paper.