Investigation of Tubewell Deterioration: Recommended, Research on Tubewell Maintenance and Rehabilitation and Suggested Invovations in Design and Construction Practices for Future Tubewells
Bibliographic details
Summary
Extensive development of irrigation in the Indus Plains without provision for drainage has caused the water table in many areas to rise to near the surface, leading to waterlogging, soil salinity, and, by the 10950's the loss of 100,000 acres of agricultural land per year. To alleviate these problems, a series of Salinity Control and Reclamation Projects (SCARPS) were undertaken, utilizing tubewells to lower the water table and provide supplementary water for relamation and irrigation. The process has resulted in one of , if not the world's largest, ground water development and control programs. In the last 15 years, some 10,000 tubewells ranging in capacity from two to five cusecs have been installed by WAPDA. The majority of the tubewells have functioned satisfactorily, but too large a percentage have experienced a rapid decline in capacity or other evidence of deterioration. This report presents findings on the causes of tubewell deterioration, suggestions on rehabilitation methods, and recommendations for improvements to tubewell design, construction, maintenance, and monitoring and research by Mr.Thomas P.Ahrens, Special consultant to Harza, who visited Pakistan in February and March of 1975. Causes of Tubewell Deterioration. The following factors have contributed to the excessively rapdi deterioration of many of the SCARP tubewell: 1. Tubewells design is standardized for an entire project and does not take into account varying conditions in the properties of the aquifer within the project area. gravel pack gradation and screen slot size in many cases are poorly matched to the aquifer. Investigations are not carried out in sufficient detail to provide for custom designing of individual tubewells. Standardization may lower first coast and expedite construction, but it leads to lower efficiency and earlier deterioration of those to be wells whose design is not consistent with their environment. 2. There are deficiencies in tubewell construction methods and in construction inspection. Methods used for placing of the gravel pack result in segregation by particle size and may lead to formation of voids that eventually could cause collapse of the tubewells screen. The tubewells are not developed adequately to flush the fine material out of the gravel pack and adjacent aquifer, and to fully develop the graded filter action of the gravel pack. Complete development of the well cannot be accomplished because the construction crews do not have the minimum required equipment. 3. There is virtually a complete lack of maintenance of the tubewells screens and gravel packs. Based on broad experience, if a tubewell has not lost more than 25 percent of its specific capacity, there is a 90 percent chance that it can be fully resotred by proper maintenance and rehabilitation. However if it has more than 50 percent of its specific capacity, there is only about a ten percent chance that it can be successfully rehabilitated. 4. Construction of tubewell projects proceeded at such a rapid pace that it was not possible to introduce improvements suggested by observation of the performance of previosuly installed tubewells, except for the major change in the mid-1960's from mild steel to fibreglass screens. In many case, there has not been a systematic program of tubewell surveillance and feed-back to the design, construction, and operation organizations.