Detailed Comments on Geotechnical Consulting Group Report 1986
Bibliographic details
Summary
GCG's recommendation on dynamic testing are inconsistent. On one hand they observe that dynamic testing is exteremely important in Pakistan and on the other hand they do not recommend dynamic test apparatus beyond preliminary level. We do not agree with their conclusions on dynamic testing equipment. If GCG agree that dynamic soil testing is necessary in Pakistan, they are not justified in deleting the shaking table and other apparatus for hynamic testing. Only items marked green have been recommended by GCG. GCG should propose comprehensive equipment to cover the full range of laboratory test for dynamic testing of rockfill has not been recommanded by GCG as Pakistan's future Projections would require the same viz basha and the current problem of liquifaction of gravel at Kakabagh/Terbela. GCG makes no mention of the need for field testing equipment required to perform tests such as geophysical tests, cone penetration tests, standard penetration tests and other institu tests which are necessary for interpretation of dynamic test results.