PakCat catalogue record

Private Tubewell Development and Groundwater Markets in Pakistan: a District Level Analysis 'Source Title' The Pakistan Development Review: an International Journal of Development Economics Volume Vol.33, no.4 (Winter 1994)

By Meinzen-Dick, Ruth

Bibliographic details

Summary

To some extent private tubewell density and water market activity are substitutes for each other, with water market sales less necessary as a higher proportion of farmers own tubewells. However, the analysis in this paper indicates that different factors affect each type of groundwater irrigation development. Environmental problems of poor quality groundwater and falling water tables decrease the density of private tubewells, while a higher proportion of poor quality groundwater significantly increases the proportion of tubewell owners participating in groundwater sales (among those tubewells which are operating). The extent of canal irrigation and the proportion of tubewell owners with medium-sized land holdings have a significant positive impact only on tubewell water sales. On the other hand, rural development characteristics of population density and literacy had a positive impact on tubewell density, but not on water sales. There is an explicit policy of promoting private tubewell development in Pakistan, particularly since the closure of public tubewells. However, there is presently no formal policy regarding water market development in Pakistan. In view of the large number of farmers, particularly smaller farmers, who depend on groundwater purchases to increase their agricultural productivity, the operation of groundwater markets merits further attention. The appropriate objectives and policy instruments for dealing with the development of both private tubewells and groundwater markets depend on the local environment, particularly the extent of recharge and groundwater quality see Strosser and Meinzen-Dick (1993). Because tubewell owners generally receive more reliable service and have higher returns than water purchasers, making tubewell ownership available to as many farmers as possible is advantageous if there are no groundwater constraints. However, if water tables are falling or of poor quality, stimulating further tubewell density is not sustainable. In such situations promoting private groundwater markets is particularly valuable to spread groundwater to as many farmers as possible. This analysis indicates that the most direct policy instruments for encouraging water market development is targeting medium-sized farmers for tubewell ownership. Well owners with 10 to 25 acres are more likely than larger farmers to have surplus water available for sale, and are more likely to provide reliable service to water purchasers. Directing credit and technical assistance for tubewell installation toward farmers in this size range will foster the development of groundwater markets and improve the equity of access to valuable groundwater resources. While this study idenitifies determinants of groundwater of groundwater market development at a national level in Pakistan, it leaves many questions unanswered. Using district-level statistics glosses over many micro-level variations which are likely to be important. Other factors (notably rural electrification) are omitted because of unavailability of data. Most importantly, it does not capture the dynamics of groundwater development. The NESPAK study provides an important baseline on the extent of private tubewell use, including water market activity. Follow-up studies could provide valuable time series information on how these changes over time, and the relationship to changes in the resource base, particularly groundwater quality and depth.