Sociological Analysis of the Forest Owners, Dwellers and Managers in the Upper Siran Valley of Hazara Division
Bibliographic details
Summary
A watershed sociological survey was carried out between March and June, 1984, in the Upper Siran Valley of Mansehra District with the objectives of better understanding the social and ethnic relationships affecting the perceptions of the local hill-dwelling people as regards land-use and possibilities for their involvement in watershed amelioration efforts. Thirty eight households in an area of approximately thirty square kilometres, deriving from seven ethnic groups, were interviewed by a team of two male and two female interviewers in an informal manner using a structured interview schedule as a basis. Members of the local and headquarters Forest Department staff were also interviewed with the aim of obtaining a balanced view of what is now a rather highly charged situation. The sociological approach employed was holistic and dialectical, with a balance struck between the practical aspects and the theoretical constructs. An attempt was made to go beyond the apparent and unravel the essence through a prolonged dialogue and keen observation. The main conclusions derived from the study are: (a) that the issues are not only highly complex, in terms of sociological relationships, but they are in addition compounded by a long tradition of largely unhindered forest exploitation by the local populace, with or without the connivance of the local forest managers. (b) that although a semi-feudal exploitative relationship still exists between the dominant (Khankhel, Swati and Sayyid) and the dominated (Gujar) ethnic groups, resulting in a general absence of developmental initiatives and a fatalistic approach to problems, there is planty of evidence that, as a result of education, travel, the influence of modern media and a recent interregnum of political socialism, the old structures are no longer accepted as they once were and that there should soon be opportunities for fresh approaches to long-standing problems. (c) that a major hurdle to be negotiated before realistic programmes dealing with land-use issues can be instigated, is that of the landlord-tenant relationship. Each side has essentially contrary interests, particularly as regards afforestation and permanent soil conservation works. (d) that the present unsatisfactory relationship between the Guzara forest owners and the forest department must be changed through modernising the management of the Guzara forests so that the forest dwellers and owners derive the maximum legal benefit possible from them. (e) that local interest in the income-generating, employment and general developmental benefits of forests should be made apparent locally through the establishment of wood-based industries in the vicinity of the forests.