"Comparative Study of Vertical and Horizontal Drainage Projects" 'Source Title' Proceedings of 5th International Drainage Workshop, February 8-15, 1992, Lahore Volume III
Bibliographic details
Summary
A comparative study of Salinity control and reclamation project-1 (SCRAP- 1) and east Khairpur Tile Drainage (EKTD) project was carried out. Internal rate of return (IRR) of both the project were calculated. Results show that the IRR of SCRAP-1 is 6% while it is 13% for the EKTD project. These results reflect that tile drainage is economical as compared to the vertical drainage. The effect of vertical and horizontal drainage projects on water quality and soil salinity were also studied. Comparison between the pre -project and the post project conditions of the two projects showed that there is no significant change in the water quality of SCARP-1, rather it deteriorated. But for the tile drainage project, there is improvement trend in the water quality. The soil salinity status of the two projects was also compared, which showed that the EKTD project is more effective to control the soil salinity.