Fourth Congress International Commission on Irrigation and Drainage Question 14: Use of Logitudinal Embankments or levees as Flood protection Measures
Bibliographic details
Summary
Longitudinal embankments or levees have been in use since time immemorial on some of the important rivers throughout the World. This is the cheapest and the simplest method of flood protection on the alluvial rivers. Though there are some disadvantages in longitudinal embankments, the advantages are so numerous that there is no question, as a general rule, of doing away with existing dikes or not constructing new ones in suitable locations. River courses can usually be divided into two parts-the upper reaches which generally lie in the hilly areas with the course more or less well defined, and the lower reaches which generally lie in alluvial plains with unpredictable courses. Rivers could be further sub-divided into three classes namely, stable, aggrading and degrading. There is no difficulty of having embankments on a stable or posed river as it does not attack the embankments. In an aggrading river, the heavy deposits of sediment make a river rather unsteady and embankments may be difficult to maintain. In degrading river rather unsteady and embankments may be difficult to maintain. In degrading rivers the danger of breaches in levees is less pronounced as the flood levels are lower. The same river could be stable, aggrading the degrading in particular reaches in its long course. The River Indus in Pakistan is one of the biggest in the World. It offers a good example of a river with embankments in its lower reaches. The rate of rise of the flood plain of the river Indus some 5000 years ago in the days of Mohanjodaro, is known thus giving the level of the river before embankments. The rate of rise of flood levels in recent years has been analysed scientifically. Longitudinal embankents affect the river regime particularly in the case of aggrading rivers as the silt which was originally deposited in the flood plain is concentrated within the embankments and helps raising the flood levels and lengthening the delta at the month of the river. In Stable rivers, embankments may not have appreciable affect on river regime. Partial embanking specially on one bank is definitely harmful. The factors affecting river regime with respect to embankments need careful study. A mathematical treatment of the problem is hardly possible. Hydraulic scale models, statistical analysis of the data and actual field experience gained can help in understanding the regime changes in a river. Embankments should not be used as a universal method for flood protection as these are not suitable in particular location such as river deltas which are still being built up like the Gauges and Brahmaputra delta in East Pakistan, or in reaches of the river which are very unstable due to any particular topographical factors. Embankments combined with other flood control measures, such as detention reservoir, river training, straightening loops, etc., is a more efficient and a desirable method.