A Comparative Study of Karez and Tubewell Irrigation Systems in Balochistan, 1990
Bibliographic details
Summary
A comparative study of T/well and karez irrigational systems in Balochistan has its significance primarily with reference to the most important sources; karez and T/well existing in the vast scattered major area of the province. In the present situation one source (T/well) is flourishing at the expense of the other (Karez). Such a dilemma is necessary is to be discussed in detail pinpointing the abondonement and drying up of Karezes based on the hydrological, social and economic reasons. Hydrological factors include the drawdown effects of dug wells and T/wells, lack of rainfall and snowfall lowering the water level of Karez contained basins in such specific alluvial fane. The social effects are more drastic, impeding the golden rule of collective maintenance of the Karezes. Moreover, the social factors include the lack of Co-operation among the shreholders, problems created by the major share holders due to their inclination towards T/wells and a desire for dominance, problems related to fund raising for maintenance, complications arising from complicated tribal set up, due to other options of irrigations (T/wells and Dug wells) and leadshuip pattern etc. Economic reasons on the other hand are mainly; the desire hold on the water source, increase in production and thus increase in income etc. The drying up Karezes with the emergence of T/wells and Dugwells has created a dilemma. Though there is legal recustomery nature, yet it has been neglected in the greater part of the province except some places like Mastung (Kalat) where the mutual agreement among the farmers is held intact. There are various reasons including the desire of hold on technology and water source, desire of dominance and of increase in yield etc., leading the farmers to incline towards T/wells. The change in form of more T/wells has deep repurcusions not confined to its drawdown effect on Karezes but has casued the collapse of traditional pattern of co-operation in management on karezes such change in traditional pattern of cooperation system withemergence of T/wells and dug wells, generally singly owned compared to collectively owned system of karez irrigation has long and deep repurcussions revealed in social and economic set up everywhere in these areas. On social side, the village organisation has changed, co-operation pattern shattered, mutural understanding weakened, selfishness merged, conflicts intensified, leadership being controlled by the T/well owners, decision making by the elders becoming biased towards the rich (T/well owners and major share holders who also are mostly T/wells owners). A sense of dominance by influentials, mostly T/wells owners is increasing, educational discrimination between the rival groups (small Karez share holders and T/well owners) becoming clearer etc. On the economic side Karez share holders (small) becoming dependent on T/well owners as they become tenants (particularly in case of dead and weak Karezes) on farms of T/well owners and also when they buy water in situation of decrease in Karez water due to siltation, increasing gap between rich and poor changing job structure due dyring up of Karezes (where T/well is one important reason) and also due to off-farm activities of the T/well owners utilising the agricultural surpluses of the past, change in cropping pattern where the Karez irrigators are confined to crops instead of orchards at present and also in the future (provided the situation remains the same) and the inability of small karez shareholders to raise live the stock etc contrary to t/well owners. In such a a situation where the area under cultivation and in the result yield is increasing the T/wells should be encouraged at the expense of Karez or not? An important consideration here is that Karez is a source of water where the maintenance cost is very important, theinitial and operational cost is not because of two reasons i) Karezes have been dug a long time ago, new Karezes are not being dug (the exceptions are there) and ii) machinery is not purpose used for operative purpose only maintenance done with traditional equipments is important to keep the Karez live. Due to very high cost of T/well particularly, installation and operational costs, it is surely an expensive source compared to Karez.