PakCat catalogue record

Performance Evaluation of Fresh Water Skimming Well Designs 1998

By Allah Bakhsh Sufi

Bibliographic details

Summary

A very serious problem of saline water occurs in the centre of all Doabs in Punjab, Pakistan. The disposal of drainage effluent into rivers is of great concern as it deteriorates river water quality for the downstream users. It has been observed that nearly 200 Bm3 of groundwater exists in the form of thin layers of fresh water over saline water, which can be explotied to augment the irrigation supplies and to provide drainage as well. Therefore, it is imperative not to disturb this saline water, but to skim the thin layer of fresh water overlying the saline water. The major aim of this study was to identify feasible skimming approaches to suit local conditions prevailing in the Indus Basin of Pakistan. For this purpose, a density dependent 3-dimensional finite element groundwater model known as VDGWTRN, was selected and modified to study partial penetration, multistrainer, radial collector, recirculation and compound/scavenger wells. The VDGWTRN model solves the continuity equation for the fluid pressure and Darcy's law for the three velocity components. This velocity is used to solve the avection-dispersion equation to find the concentration, and this information is used to update the density profile in the flow equation. In problems dominated by advection, this model gives realistic solutions. The VDGWTRN model simulates the density depenedent contaiinant transport in sincle and multiple horizontal or sloping aquifer systems with either a confined or unconfined aquifer. The Galerkin finite element formulation for the set of the nonlinear partial differential equations that describe the movement of the contaminant obtains the velocity and pressure to guarantee the continuity of velocity between elements. This model calculates the mass balance for both flow and solute transport after each time step. The model was verified with field result from skimming wells installed at the Mona Project, WAPDA and scavenger wells installed at LBOD Project, WAPDA. The observed and computed results showed good agreement. The physical modeling was also performed to investigate the skimming phenomena using single, multi-strainer, radial recirculation and compound well configurations. The physical model has indicated a good response regarding fresh water skimming. The numerical model was calibrated using the physical model results. The numerical and physical simulation results reveal that the performance of two strainer well was relatively better. The radial well has shown useful results. But in field conditions, the horizontal boring for radial well installation at relatively deeper depths where good aquifer conditions are available, will be problem and some special technique wiil be required, which will raise the cost. However, at shallower depths sump drainage can be considered. The recirculation well technique with recharge under gravity to an extent of 30 percent of the main well discharge has indicated good performance. The recharge near the abstraction end of the main well reduced upconing significantly. The performance of compound/scavenger well with a 1:1 fresh and saline water recovery ration was found to be good for suppressing upconing. However, this technique is prone to have severe problems for disposal of saline effluent. It has been found that two strainer, radial collector and recirculation techniques of fresh water skimming are better atlernatives as compared to compund/scavenger wells. The presence of an aquitard plasy a significant role in reducing upconing. Intermittent pumping alos gave encouraging results with 50 percent use efficiency. Two-strainer well technique is proved to be the most suitable one for skimming fresh water underlain by saline water. Further, it is recommended that radial collector and recirculation wells should be tested in field, to establish their efficiency.