PakCat catalogue record

Transition from Local Level Management to State Regulation: Formalization of Water Allocation Rules in Pakistan

By Mehmood ul Hassan

Bibliographic details

Summary

Theorists have identified various factors that promote or prohibit collective action at the local level. Various schools of thought attempt explaining collective action from various perspectives. This study addresses the basic question of why the state regulated pakka warabandi replaced irrigation water resources management at the local level. A case study approach has been followed. Farmers had already been practicing very effective water distribution at tertiary irrigation level under a kachcha warabandi arrangement. This organization dissolved, depicted in this study met almost all the standards laid down by earlier research. Results indicate that some users were acutely affected by unreliable water supplies, which the organization as sacred symbol of tradition, as well as dealing with the unreliability as an exogenous variable. Dissatisfied members vetoed these, and invited state regulated warabandi, which does not ensure reliability as such, but specifies the time and duration of irrigation turns for each user. Therefore, this study argues that technical factors form the root cause that triggers off social complications. These social complications challenge the potential of the organization and its aptness to mitigate the technical issue. If the organization cannot meet the challenge, the collective action is discarded. Thus, the presence, or absence, of collective action hings upon the technical appropriateness of the organization and its ability to cope with the soical constraints.