An Assessment of Warabandi (Irrigation Rotation) in Pakistan: a Preliminary Analysis 'Source Title' The Pakistan Development Review: an International Journal of Development Economics Volume Vol.33, no.4 (Winter 1994)
Bibliographic details
Summary
The performance of the warabandi system has been evaluated on one watercourse in Faisalabad district. Data from 30 formers were collected regarding cultivable command area, net irrigated area and frequency of irrigation in both seasons namely Rabi and Kharif. Ratios of net irrigated area and total irrigated area to CCA were estimated. Theil Index (TIC) was computed to evaluate the performance of the warabandi system. The TWA/CCA ratios show that the system is working at 104 percent as against expected output of 133 percent. The TIC is computed at 37 percent, which implies that the system is working at 63 percent effectiveness. The comparison with an Indian study [Seckler (1980)] shows that Pakistan's warabandi system is less effective than that in the Indian Punjab. The results of the study confirm the widely held belief that the system of warabandi in the Indus Basin is not flexible enough to use the vital water resource in an efficient manner. The institutional rigidity of the system causes large conveyance losses and hampers the consumptive needs of the crops. Farmers tend to under-irrigate the fields which, given other things, adversely affects the yields of crops. There is ample evidence of surface water trading and water markets for underground water. The system of warabandi needs to be modified to allow water trading and development of water markets for surface water. The farmers should be assigned proprietary rights to irrigation so that they can use this precious resource where it has high marginal productivity. The use of this resource be demand-led than supply-driven. It should be priced at least at its marginal cost so as to generate enough resources for the proper maintenance of the canal network. This policy change will also encourage the conjunctive use of surface and underground water. Results from the IFPRI study Ruth (1993) indicate that use of groundwater in conjunction with canal irrigation increases productivity. Based on the consumptive needs of crops and stress function, the duration of the the warabandi may also be changed from present 7 days rotation to 15 days rotation. Accordingly allocation of water to each farmer during his turn should be increased. In this way net irrigated area can be increased and crops will get water according to the consumptive needs. This will also reduce the water losses that occur during weekly rotations.