PakCat catalogue record

Achievements and Issues of Watershed Management in the 20th Century 'Source Title' Proceedings of the National Workshop on Water Resources Achievements and Issues in 20th Century and Challenges for the Next Millennium, Islamabad - Pakistan, 28-30 June 1999

By Shahid Ahmad

Bibliographic details

Summary

The major part of the northern mountains and a part of the Pothwar plateau constitute the major watersheds draining to the tributaries of the Indus Rivers System. Infact, the watersheds of Tarbela, Mangla and many small dams fall in to this area. These watersheds have unfortunately suffered from excessive and wide spread felling of woody vegetation and have overgrazing in the past century. The sediment is subsequently deposited in streams, channels, lakes, reservoirs and harbors, requiring costly remedial measures to keep up their useful lives. Sediment studies in Pakistan's rivers have been carried out since 1916. The geologic erosion is predominated in the watersheds of the Indus, Kabul and Swat rivers, whereas accelerated erosion is caused by defective landuse in the watersheds of other tributaries of Indus and Jhelum. The forest area is only 5% of the country's geographical area and is defined legally and not biologically because of the definitional difficulty due to colonial legacy and thus area is insensitive to the number of trees. The Indus river system is being operated in accordance with Indus Water Treaty and Indus Water Apportionment Accord. The systematic watershed management programme in the Tarbela and Mangla dams were started in early 60s using traditional approaches. The active participation of communities started in early and mid 80s under the integrated mountain development programs. The early traditional programs had a reasonable effect in Mangla dam area compared to the Tarbela dam. Coupled with recent participatory approaches, the watershed management in Mangla dam had reasonable impact on reduction of sediment load to the streams entering the Mangla lake and now the predicted life will be around 182 years instead of 110 years of the designed life. Whereas, there is no significant improvement in reducing the sediment load to streams entering the Tarbela dam primarily due to excessive geologic erosion in the watershed area. The integrated development and rural support programs introduced during 90s resulted into active participation of communities in managing natural resources of these watersheds and maintaining equity in access to increase community livelihoods. These programs were also very successful in addressing the issues of the neglected segments of communities especially landless and women. The paper recommends that the success of watershed management programs depends on the optimal blend of social, economic, ecological, political and site-specific realities through active participation of communities. The project approach is too much focussed on targets and there is a need to have a program approach instead of getting stuck in the dialogue of bottom-up or top-down approach. Infact, there is a need to have a balance approach. The other issues related to technological, social and management aspects were described and recommendations were made. The most critical recommendation is that watershed problems must be seen from the management and social end instead of merely the technological end.