Institutions for Managing Lakes and Bays 'Source Title' Selected Works in Water Resources
Bibliographic details
Summary
The adequacy of the Nation's public institutions is being called into question in many if not most areas of public affairs. Organizational tinkering no longer satisfies the discontent. The questioning goes to basic premises of our culture and it calls for a fundamental reassessment of the institutions needed to respond to contemporary problems and challenges. Environmental quality has emerged as a sector of public affairs in which discontent and institutional challenges are marked. The study on which this paper is based undertakes to explore an approach to a fundamental reassessment of institutional needs for dealing with one type of environmental unit that represented by lakes and bays. The study postulates a framework for institutional analysis and design synthesized from cultural premises theoretical concepts and normative assumptions which are made explicit to the extent they are known and identifiable. Four principal components of the framework are: (1) definitions of the problems of lakes and bays which prompt the present state of dissatisfaction: (2) definition of the job to be done in terms of the perspective of society as a whole; (3) definition of institutional policy based upon the premises that questions of public intervention in status quo are central to policy choices and institutional arrangements: and (4) definition of the social political process of institutional design. The present paper proceeds to explore the questions raised and problems confronted in applying the institutional design process to establishing a lake/bay agency. From exploring the process of designing a lake/bay agency several preliminary conclusions or observations may be noted. First, it became evident early in the study that there is no one right institutional pattern for managing lakes and bays. This preception was reinforced again and again in the process of thinking through the framework for institutional analysis and design. Rather than an organization or a pattern of institutional arrangements, the appropriate institutional response will vary from situation to situation. Accordingly, the study turned to identify variables influencing of regional institutional forms is postulated to range from a regional management agency with extensive powers to plan and regulate and to finance and operate projects, to an instrument of regional governance in which the lake/bay agency would concentrate on developing regional goals regarding lake/bay use and articulating the interests of the lake/bay community. Accepting the premise that there may be a range of lake/bay organizations appropriate to varying circumstances lead to a second conclusion that the operational linkages between the lake/bay agency and other relevant agencies of general government should be a major concern of institutional design. In fact, it might be claimed that organization reform has in the past mistakenly sought to sharpen the