PakCat catalogue record

The Appropriateness of Canal Water Supplies, The Response of the Farmers, A case study in the Fordwah Eastern Sadiqia Area Punjab, Pakistan, 1992

By Kuper, Marcel

Bibliographic details

Summary

When the irrigation systems serving the Fordwah/Eastern Sadiqia area were designed (around 1930), some canals were made non-perennial for fear of developing waterlogging in riparian areas of Sutlej river. Present day operation of the Fordwah Branch does not seem to justify continution of this practice, and the historical reasons are not relevant anymore. It is recommended to review this matter and in doing so to consider the managerial and operational advantages of making all distributaries perennial. The operation of the irrigation system is not based on offical rules only. Informal consideration, e.g.based on the perceived differences in groundwater quality in the various command areas, enter also into decisions on water distribution. Moreover, it has been observed that farmers themselves can and do influence that process, by their degree of organixation and cooperation. It is recommended that these informal aspects of water distribution are studied further and that the positive role farmers can play be stimulated. Irrigation Department staff should view the increasing number of informal groups of water users as an oportunity for soliving previously intractable problems, such as illegal irrigation, maintenance of some stretches of canal, and repairs of breaches, rather than as an intrusion on ID's responsibilities. The amount of water available to farmers is site-specific, as it varies between distributaris and depends on location along the distributary. underlying cases are the degree of siltation, which alters the hydraulic features of outlest, and illegal irrigations. Illegal approporiation of wate occur in many command areas, and deserve more attention from the Irrigation Department than they presently receive. It is recommanded that the ID starts to address both causes of the apparent inequity in distribution. Annual values of irrigation water quality at farm level are governed by the proportions of canal water and groundwater received during the year, and the quality of the latter. It was found that the average water quality was higher for Fordwah command area than for Azim because of the disproportionately low accessibility to canal water for Azim farmers. It is recommended that in the distribution of canal water more attention is paid to water quality, to ensure equity of amounts and of water quality, in order to prevent the build-up of salts in rootzones of irrigated lands. The intensive desilting that took place as aprt of a state-wide desiltation campain during annual closure of 1992, complemented in the study area by remodelling of outlets in head and middle reaches of distributaries, has led to an imporved equity of water distribution accoring to the analysis of Rabi data for the period following annual closure. It is recommended to monitor water distribution in the distributary canals to establish the sustainability of the improved equity, especially when farmers demands for water are at its peak during early Kharif. Farmers mix canal and tubewell supplies to increase discharge in watercourses and compensate for low quality of groundwater. The total relative water supplies (RWS) are of the same order of magnitude (0.8-0.9) for all watercourses that were monitored. This is taken as indication for the fact that farmers are stretching the irrigation water to cover as large an area as possible. It is recommended to further study irrigation applications by farmers to their crops, the proportions of water from groundwater, its quality, and the effect on yiled. Tubewell development in the area is a response by farmers to the scarcity of canal water, and to the inflexibility of canal water delivery. Water from tubewells augments scarce canal water and provides flexibility in water allocations. The share of groundwater in the total irrigation supplies ranges from 20% in the head reach of Fordwah command to 84% in the tail reach of Azim. Operation and maintenance costs were found to affect the utilization rates of tubewells with electric tubewells. It is recommended to the ID to develop conjunctive management of groundwater and canal water, and if it is desirable to further develop groundwater resources in (parts of) the area (something that needs to be investigated thoroughly), to stimulate WAPDA to extend electrification in the region to allow farmers to install electri tubewells. Highly active water trading in the study area supports the notion that farmers desire a more flexible water supply system. All farmers without tubewells reported the purchase of tubewells water, to the extent that 20 to 40% of the pumped groundwater was sold to others. Generally low utilization rates of tubewells (10% on the average in the study area) indicate that there is room to enchance the trade in tubewell water. It is recommended that water rading should be an integral part of the conunctive management of canal water and groundwater in the area. Better understanding of trading mechnisms and water pricing is, therefore, needed. The present document is a first report of the existing management and irrigation practices in (part of) the Fordwah/Eastern Sadiqia area. It identifies constraints in operation of the irrigation system and opportunities for improved management of groundwater and canal water. It is recommended that similar fairly intensive studies are carried out in other parts of the Fordwah/Eastern Sadiqia area, especially in view of the expressed interest of the government of Punjab to have an extensive sub-surface drainage system installed in the southern part of the area. It is recommended that IIMI and ID joinly implement some/all of the recommendations mentioned above, and identify and implement possible improvements in the management of irrigation in the area.