PakCat catalogue record

Electrical Analog Studies on the Lower Thal Doab Project Area (Scrap-3)

By Gilani, Maqsood Ali Shah

Bibliographic details

Summary

The following conclusions can be drawn from the studies made on the electric analog model of SCARP-3 area:- ; 1. The value of coefficient of transmissibility of the aquifer in Lower Thal Doab is probably higher than the value used in the feasibility report published by Messrs. Tipton and Kalmbach, consultants to WAPDA. The value of T used in the feasibiliyt report is 4 X 10-5 gpd/ft. Whereas the analog model analysis of the steady state conditions, which existed prior to the period of year 1935, indicaters that the value of coefficient of transmissibility may be on the order of 1.2 X 10-6 gpd/ft. The higher value of transmissibility was inferred from steady state analysis under the assumption that rivers act as constant head boundares and that net area discharge (evapotranspiration minus deep percolation) is in the order of magnitude described in the report. This order of net areal discharge can be justified on the basis of the work of others. Using the input data proposed in the feasibility report published by Messrs Tipton and Kalmbach, model analysis indicates that there is an overall decline in groundwater levels. The maximum drawdonw is obtained in main zone of the project area, where the decline is 48 feet, 70 feet and 80 feet for 10 years, 20 years and 50 years, respectively, of project operation. In the strip zone of the project area the order to maximum decline is 31 feet. There is a general high order of decline int he poor water quality zone. The order of decline in groundwater levels in this zone coincides with the maximum value of decline in the project area. This is due to the fact that besides the net withdrawal of 0.182 MAF/year for this zone, pumping in the surrounding main zone has also influenced the decline in water levels in the poor water quality zone. When the revised input data are applied (given on page 28), different patterns of groundwater level changes are obtained. In this case, there is a general rise in ground-water levels in the poor quality water zone. Maximum rise is obtained when the value of transmissibility used was 4000000 gpd/ft. The magnitude of rise in the ground-water levels in this zone decreases with increaes in the value of transmissibility and the period of pumping. The rise in the zone has occured due to the net recharge over this area. However, in the area underlain by fresh quality ground-water, there is an overall decline in groundwater levels. The maximum decline is obtained in the main zone of the project area. Low values of drawdown are observed in proximity to the rivers and the unpumped central area of mineralized ground-water. Considerration of the exteneded aquifer on the other sides of the rivers Indus and Chenab and neglecting the influences of rivers on the groundwater system in view of the low flows in them due to the construction of future Indus Basin replacement works, it has been found that ground-water levels decline mroe rapdily. This would be the extreme case of lowering of water-levels in response to the data proposed by the personnel of Tipton and Kalmbach as described on page 28. The declines in ground-water levels in this case are nearly double than those obtained when the rivers were considered as constant head boundaries. The water-levels decline or rise do not seem to be very realistic as the concerns of areal recharge as proposed by Tipton and Kalambach might have to be modified. The water levels at the start of the project are almost in equilibrium and the area of recharge in the saline zone might be compensated by the rates of evapotranspiration. The rise in the ground-water levels in this zone as observed in the model study, therefore, exhibits appromiately the magnitude of evapotranspiration acting on this zone. Also the active areal recharge in the saline zone would flush salt water into the fresh water zone. The canals in SCARP-3 have been considered as active line recharge sources. The possible justification may actually be induced recharge from these canals depending on the head decline in ground-water levels due to pumping. The influence of pumping in SCARP-3 on the adjacent Upper Thal Doab and the aquifers on far sides of the rivers Indus and Chenab is significant. Whenever a new project is planned, the effects of previous adjoining projects already in operation opon the newly planned project should be taken into consideration. Out of the five experiments carried out during the present analong model study in four cases the storage in aquifers beyond the rivers Indus and Chenab has been simulated by the constant head boundaries. In the fifth case when the storage in aquifers beyond the rivers Indus and Chenab was simulated as continous with the aquifer of SCARP-3, the effect of SCARP-3 operation is evidently reflected in the adacent aquifers. Therefore, stress due to development in the adjacent areas will eventually be felt in SCARP-3. area. This points out that a continued work on this model and adjacent area should be carried out in future. A composite model of the region will be needed to assess actual regional response.